Extension of Tax Audit Filing Deadline for AY 2024-25

 The deadline to submit the income tax audit report has been extended to October 7, 2024, for taxpayers who are legally required to conduct an income tax audit of their accounts. Originally set for September 30, 2024, this extension provides taxpayers and professionals with additional time to file their reports without penalties.

Key Details:

• Extended Deadline: October 7, 2024
• Original Deadline: September 30, 2024
• Penalty for Late Filing: A fine of Rs. 1.5 lakh or 0.5% of total sales, whichever is lower, will apply for late submissions.
• Online Submission Requirement: The audit report must be filed electronically via the e-filing portal of the Income Tax Department.

This extension offers critical relief, especially considering the high penalties associated with late filing. Taxpayers are encouraged to utilize this additional time wisely and avoid last-minute submissions, ensuring compliance with audit requirements.

Streamlining Compliance: Simplified Directors' Report and Annual Return Filing under the Companies Act, 2013

The Companies Act, 2013 mandates that every company prepares and presents a Directors' Report as part of its annual financial statements. This report provides key insights into the company's financial performance, future outlook, corporate governance, and statutory compliance. However, recent amendments to the Act have significantly simplified the filing requirements, particularly for small companies and businesses without websites. These changes aim to reduce compliance burdens while maintaining transparency for stakeholders.

This guidance note explores the latest amendments regarding the Directors' Report and annual return, exemptions for certain companies, and a detailed analysis of the reporting obligations under Section 92(3) and Section 134(3)(a) of the Companies Act, 2013.

Key Amendments in Filing the Directors' Report and Annual Return

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) introduced amendments in 2020 and 2021, which simplified the Directors' Report and annual return filing processes. The amendments impact the requirements for disclosing annual returns on the company’s website and have relieved small companies and others from attaching unnecessary documents.

1. Section 92(3) – Annual Return Disclosure on Website

• Old Requirement: Previously, Section 92(3) required every company to attach the extract of the annual return (Form MGT-9) to the Directors' Report.
• Amended Requirement: As per the Companies (Amendment) Act, 2017, companies are no longer required to attach Form MGT-9. Instead, companies with a website must place the annual return on their website and include a web-link in the Directors' Report.

The key point here is that only companies with websites must display their annual return online. For companies without a website, this disclosure requirement does not apply.

2. Section 134(3)(a) – Simplified Directors' Report

• Old Requirement: Companies were required to provide extensive details, including attaching the extract of the annual return (MGT-9) with the Directors' Report.
• Amended Requirement: Section 134(3)(a) now only requires companies to include the web address where the annual return has been placed, if applicable. The need to attach Form MGT-9 has been removed, simplifying the reporting process significantly.

These amendments align with the government’s Ease of Doing Business initiative, reducing redundant documentation for businesses.

Who Needs to Display the Directors' Report on the Website?

The amendments make it clear that only certain companies are required to upload the Directors' Report and annual return on their websites. Below are the specific guidelines for different types of companies:

Companies Required to Display the Annual Return and Directors' Report Online:

1. Public Companies:
   • If a public company maintains a website, it must place a copy of its annual return on the website and include the web-link in the Directors' Report.
2. Private Companies with Websites:
   • Private companies that operate a website must also comply by placing their annual return online and disclosing the web-link in the Directors' Report.
3. Small Companies with Websites:
   • Small companies, as defined under Section 2(85) of the Act, are required to place their annual return on their websites if they have one and include the web-link in their Directors' Report.

Exemptions for Companies without Websites:

Companies that do not maintain a website are exempt from the requirement to disclose the annual return or the Directors' Report online. Additionally, they do not need to provide any web-link in their Directors' Report.

This exemption applies to:

• Public Companies without websites.
• Private Companies without websites.
• Small Companies without websites.

Amendments that Simplify Compliance

The following changes introduced by the MCA further simplify the filing and disclosure requirements for companies:

1. MCA Notification – Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2021

• The Companies (Management and Administration) Amendment Rules, 2021 eliminated the need for companies to attach the extract of the annual return (MGT-9), even if they do not have a website.
• As a result, no company, irrespective of size or website status, needs to attach Form MGT-9 to their Directors' Report anymore. This significantly reduces the compliance burden for small and medium-sized businesses.

2. Simplified Annual Return for Small Companies

• Small companies can now file their annual return using e-Form MGT-7A, a simplified form designed specifically for small companies, reducing the complexity of reporting.
• These companies must place the e-Form MGT-7A on their website (if they have one) and disclose the web-link in the Directors' Report.

Exemptions and Simplifications for Small Companies and Others

The MCA has introduced several key exemptions and simplified compliance measures, particularly for small companies and businesses without websites.

Company Type	Requirement to Display Annual Return on Website	Disclosure of Web-Link in Directors' Report	Exemption Status
Public Companies with Websites	Yes	Must disclose the web-link in the Directors' Report.	No exemption
Private Companies with Websites	Yes	Must disclose the web-link in the Directors' Report.	No exemption
Small Companies with Websites	Yes	Must disclose the web-link in the Directors' Report.	No exemption
Companies without Websites	No	Not required to disclose the web-link or attach MGT-9.	Exempt from placing the annual return online
Small Companies without Websites	No	Not required to disclose the web-link or attach MGT-9.	Exempt from placing the annual return online

Latest Compliance Measures for Annual Return Filing

In addition to the exemptions discussed, companies must ensure that they comply with the latest filing rules for the annual return:

1. E-Form MGT-7 or MGT-7A (for small companies) must be filed with the Registrar of Companies (ROC).
2. Companies with a website must ensure that their annual return is uploaded on the website and the web-link is provided in the Directors' Report.

Conclusion: Simplified Compliance for a Transparent Corporate Ecosystem

The amendments to the Companies Act, 2013 offer significant relief to companies, particularly small companies and businesses without websites. The removal of the requirement to attach Form MGT-9 and the simplification of the Directors' Report and annual return filing process make it easier for companies to comply with statutory obligations.

While companies with websites must still disclose their annual returns online, those without websites enjoy exemptions that ease their reporting burdens. These reforms contribute to creating a more business-friendly environment, aligning with India’s Ease of Doing Business initiative, while maintaining corporate transparency and accountability.

Analysis of Form 10B and Form 10BB for Charitable and Religious Organizations

In the realm of charitable and religious organizations, compliance with tax regulations is critical for maintaining tax-exempt status under Sections 12A and 10(23C) of the Income Tax Act. Form 10B and Form 10BB play pivotal roles in this compliance framework, ensuring organizations meet necessary requirements and avoid penalties. This detailed analysis explores the filing requirements, income thresholds, exemptions, compliance procedures, and consequences of non-compliance, supported by illustrative examples.

Key Differentiators: Form 10B vs. Form 10BB

Criteria	Form 10B	Form 10BB
Applicable Income Threshold	Total income exceeds ₹5 crore	Total income is below ₹5 crore
Foreign Contributions (FCRA)	Applicable if the entity received foreign contributions	Not applicable if no foreign contributions are received
Income Applied Outside India	Applicable if income is applied outside India	Only applicable for income applied within India
Audit Requirement	Required for Section 12A registered trusts	Required for Section 10(23C) organizations
Due Date for Filing	30th September 2024 (Audit case: 31st October 2024)	30th September 2024

Critical Analysis

1. Threshold Impact

The threshold of ₹5 crore serves as a significant determinant in choosing the appropriate form. Organizations with total income exceeding this threshold must file Form 10B, while those below it must file Form 10BB. Selecting the incorrect form can lead to the disallowance of tax exemptions, alongside penalties under Section 271B.

2. Foreign Contributions

Organizations receiving foreign donations are required to file Form 10B, regardless of their income level. This ensures regulatory oversight on foreign donations, thereby linking FCRA registration with Form 10B filing, and maintaining transparency in financial dealings.

Exemptions from Filing Form 10B/10BB or Conducting Audit

Certain organizations may be exempt from filing these forms under specific conditions. Understanding these exemptions is crucial to avoid unnecessary audits and penalties.

Exemption Scenarios

Exemption Condition	Details
Gross Receipts Below ₹2.5 Lakh	Charitable or religious trusts with gross receipts under ₹2.5 lakh are exempt from audit requirements and filing either form.
Not Registered Under Section 12A/10(23C)	Organizations not registered under these sections are not required to file either form but cannot claim tax benefits.
Application of 85% Income for Charitable Purposes	Entities that have utilized 85% or more of their income for charitable purposes within India are generally exempt from further filings beyond their ITR.

Critical Analysis

• Risk of Non-Filing: Smaller organizations may overlook filing requirements due to exemption thresholds, risking scrutiny if income levels or donations rise unexpectedly. Continuous monitoring of gross receipts is vital for compliance.

• 85% Expenditure Rule: Meeting the 85% application threshold for charitable purposes is fundamental for retaining tax-exempt status. Failing to meet this threshold without filing Form 9A or Form 10 leads to immediate taxability of unspent income under Section 11(2).

Step-by-Step Compliance Procedure for Form 10B and Form 10BB

1. Determine Income and Foreign Contributions

Assess your organization’s gross receipts to confirm whether total income exceeds ₹5 crore. Organizations receiving foreign contributions must comply with FCRA regulations and file Form 10B, regardless of income level.

2. 85% Expenditure Compliance

Ensure that 85% or more of the income is applied to charitable purposes. If this threshold is not met, the following actions are required:

Expenditure Level	Required Action
85% or more of income applied	No additional forms required; file Form 10B or 10BB as applicable.
Less than 85% of income applied	File Form 9A to carry forward unspent income to the next year.
Accumulation for Specific Purpose	File Form 10 for income accumulation, specifying the purpose for the unspent amount.

3. Filing the Correct Form

File either Form 10B or Form 10BB based on your organization’s income and contribution type. Discrepancies could lead to penalties and loss of tax exemptions.

Scenario	Applicable Form	Key Compliance Points
Income above ₹5 crore	Form 10B	Must file alongside ITR-7; foreign contributions require FCRA compliance.
Income below ₹5 crore	Form 10BB	Must file alongside ITR-7; primarily for domestic charitable purposes.

4. Audit Report Submission

Ensure the audit report is signed by a qualified Chartered Accountant and submitted on time. For organizations with income exceeding ₹5 crore, the audit report under Form 10B is mandatory.

Other Key Compliances and Filing Requirements

In addition to core filings, charitable and religious organizations must comply with various other legal and procedural requirements to avoid defaults:

Compliance	Form/Section	Due Date	Critical Points
Section 12A Registration	Form 10A	At setup/renewal	Essential for tax exemptions; apply for renewal before expiry.
Expenditure of 85% of Income	Form 9A	Before ITR due date	File to carry forward unspent income; avoid immediate taxation.
Accumulation of Income	Form 10	Before ITR due date	Failure to file leads to taxability of accumulated income.
FCRA Compliance for Foreign Donations	Form FC-4	31st December annually	Non-compliance leads to penalties and cancellation of FCRA license.

Critical Analysis

• Form 9A and Form 10: These forms are crucial for entities not meeting the 85% expenditure threshold. Failure to file these forms timely exposes the organization to tax on unspent income.

• FCRA Compliance: Stringent requirements apply to entities receiving foreign donations. Non-compliance with Form FC-4 can result in severe penalties, including cancellation of the FCRA license.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

Non-compliance with filing requirements can lead to substantial penalties:

Type of Penalty	Section	Reason	Penalty Amount
Failure to file audit report	Section 271B	Not submitting Form 10B or Form 10BB	0.5% of total sales, turnover, or gross receipts, subject to a maximum of ₹1.5 lakh
Incorrect Form Submission	Section 271A	Wrong filing can result in penalties	Penalty up to ₹25,000
Failure to comply with FCRA	Section 14	Non-filing of Form FC-4	Penalties vary; could lead to license cancellation

Final Thoughts

Navigating the complexities of Form 10B and Form 10BB is essential for charitable and religious organizations to maintain compliance and avoid costly penalties. Continuous monitoring of financials, timely filing, and meticulous documentation practices are crucial to safeguarding tax-exempt status and fulfilling regulatory obligations. Understanding the nuances of these forms not only ensures compliance but also fosters trust and transparency in the philanthropic landscape.  

FCA Surekha Ahuja

Mastering GST Refunds: Your Essential Guide to Fixing Bank Account Errors

If you find yourself in a situation where your GST refund shows as disbursed on the GST portal but hasn’t reached your bank account, you’re not alone. This issue commonly arises from incorrect bank account details provided during the refund application process. This guide will walk you through the steps to resolve this issue efficiently, ensuring you can access your funds without unnecessary delays.

The Scenario

Your GST refund is indicated as successfully disbursed, yet you haven’t received the funds in your bank account. After checking with your bank, you discovered that the account number recorded in RFD-05 was incorrect. This oversight can hinder timely access to your refund, making it crucial to act quickly.

Importance of Accurate Bank Details

• Timely Processing: Correct information ensures that refunds are processed and credited swiftly.
• Avoiding Complications: Mistakes in bank details can lead to misdirected funds or prolonged waiting periods.
• Cash Flow Management: Accessing your refunds promptly is vital for maintaining business operations.

Step-by-Step Resolution Process

Step 1: Verify Your Bank Account Details

1. Log into the GST Portal:

   • Use your GST credentials to access your account.

2. Check the Refund Application:

   • Go to Services > Refunds > Track Application Status.
   • Carefully review the account number listed in your application.

3. Note Discrepancies:

   • Identify the incorrect account number and compare it with your actual bank details.

Step 2: Gather Necessary Documentation

1. Collect Required Documents:

   • Obtain a cancelled cheque displaying the correct bank account number.
   • Secure a bank statement that confirms your name and the accurate account details.

2. Organize Your Files:

   • Ensure all documents are clear and ready for submission.

Step 3: Submit a Rectification Application

1. Prepare a New Application:

   • Navigate back to the GST portal and head to the Refunds section.

2. Fill Out RFD-05:

   • Initiate a new application, ensuring the correct bank account information is entered.
   • Double-check all details to prevent further errors.

3. Upload Your Documents:

   • Attach the cancelled cheque and bank statement as proof of the correct account.

4. Submit the Application:

   • Ensure that the application is submitted successfully and save the acknowledgment number.

Step 4: Contact the GST Helpdesk

1. Reach Out for Assistance:

   • Get in touch with the GST Helpdesk via their contact number or email.

2. Provide Key Information:

   • Share your application reference number, the incorrect bank account number, and the correct details.

3. Request Confirmation:

   • Confirm that your rectification request has been received and inquire about any next steps.

Step 5: Engage with Your Bank

1. Speak to Your Bank’s Customer Service:

   • Discuss the situation with your bank's support team.

2. Verify Account Status:

   • Check that there are no restrictions or issues with your bank account preventing the refund's credit.

3. Look for Pending Transactions:

   • Ensure there are no outstanding transactions that might impact the GST refund.

Step 6: Monitor the Status of Your Refund

1. Regularly Check the GST Portal:

   • Log in periodically to see the status of your refund application.

2. Watch Your Bank Account:

   • Keep an eye on your account for any incoming transfers related to the refund.

Step 7: Persistent Follow-Up

1. Follow Up with the GST Helpdesk:

   • If there are no updates, maintain communication with the GST Helpdesk.

2. Document All Communications:

   • Keep a record of all interactions, including dates and details of conversations for future reference.

Conclusion

Resolving issues related to GST refunds due to incorrect bank account details may seem daunting, but with a structured approach, you can tackle this efficiently. By following the outlined steps, you’ll be well on your way to rectifying the situation and receiving your refund. Remember, effective communication with both the GST Helpdesk and your bank is key to a smooth resolution. Taking prompt action will help ensure you regain access to your funds quickly and without unnecessary complications.

Audit Trail Integrity for Reliable Financial Reporting - Draft Clause in Different Situations

In an independent auditor's report, it is crucial to assess the integrity of a company’s accounting records and the adequacy of its internal controls related to financial reporting. The following variations of Clause VI address different scenarios encountered during the audit for the financial year ended March 31, 2024. Each scenario reflects the specific circumstances surrounding the company’s accounting practices and the implications for audit trail preservation.

Clause VI: Company Using Manual Accounting Systems

Clause VI: Auditor's Report Clause

Audit Trail Integrity: Based on our examination, which included a review of internal controls and transaction testing, we noted that the Company maintained its books of account using a manual accounting system for the financial year ended March 31, 2024. As this system does not provide for an automated audit trail (edit log), the traditional concept of an audit trail does not apply. However, we found that the Company has established adequate documentation procedures to maintain accuracy and accountability in its financial reporting.

Clause VI: Company with Incomplete Records

Clause VI: Auditor's Report Clause

Audit Trail Integrity: Our examination, which included substantive testing and analytical review, revealed that the Company utilized accounting software for maintaining its financial records for the financial year ended March 31, 2024. However, we identified several discrepancies and incomplete entries. While the software includes an audit trail (edit log) feature, our review indicated that it was not fully operational for all relevant transactions. We did not find any instances of tampering with the audit trail feature during our audit.

Given the proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, effective from April 1, 2023, the requirement to report under Rule 11(g) of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014 regarding the preservation of an audit trail does not apply to the financial year ended March 31, 2024.

Clause VI: Company Transitioning to New Accounting Software

Clause VI: Auditor's Report Clause

Audit Trail Integrity: Based on our examination, which included system controls testing and transaction validation, we observed that the Company transitioned to a new accounting software for maintaining its financial records for the year ended March 31, 2024. The new software is equipped with an audit trail (edit log) feature, but we noted that its implementation was completed only midway through the financial year, resulting in incomplete audit trail coverage for some transactions.

In line with the proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, effective April 1, 2023, the requirement to report under Rule 11(g) of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014 concerning the preservation of the audit trail does not pertain to the financial year ended March 31, 2024.

Clause VI: Company with an Automated System but No Audit Trail Feature

Clause VI: Auditor's Report Clause

Audit Trail Integrity: Our examination involved various test checks and an assessment of internal controls, revealing that the Company employed an automated accounting system for maintaining its financial records for the year ended March 31, 2024. Notably, the software does not incorporate an audit trail (edit log) feature, limiting the ability to track modifications to the records. Nonetheless, we found that the Company has implemented adequate documentation practices and internal controls to ensure transparency and accountability.

In accordance with the proviso to Rule 3(1) of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, effective April 1, 2023, the requirement to report under Rule 11(g) of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014 regarding audit trail preservation is not applicable for the financial year ended March 31, 2024.

---

Empowering Your Business: Essential Strategies for Compliant Bookkeeping in the Digital Era

In the ever-evolving landscape of corporate governance in India, maintaining accurate and compliant books of account is crucial for the operational integrity of companies. This guidance note consolidates essential legal frameworks, compliance requirements, penalties for defaults, and best practices as mandated by the Companies Act, 2013 and other relevant regulations.

1. Legal Framework Under the Companies Act, 2013

1.1. Section 128: Maintenance of Books of Account

• Legal Language: "Every company shall prepare and keep at its registered office, or at such other place as may be decided by the Board, books of account and other relevant papers and financial statements for the current year and for the last eight financial years."
• Interpretation: Companies must maintain comprehensive and accurate books of account reflecting their financial position. Records can be kept at the registered office or any location within India, provided this is notified to the Registrar of Companies (RoC) via Form AOC-5.

1.2. Definition of Books of Account

• Legal Language: According to Section 2(13) of the Companies Act, 2013, "Books of account" shall include:
  1. Records of all sums of money received and expended.
  2. Records of all sales and purchases of goods.
  3. Records of all assets and liabilities.
  4. Records of all other matters related to the business.

These records serve as the foundation for preparing financial statements and provide a transparent view of the company’s financial health.

1.3. Section 134: Financial Statements

• Legal Language: "The financial statements shall give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the company, comply with the accounting standards, and shall be signed by the chairperson."
• Interpretation: Financial statements must be prepared from the maintained books of account and adhere to applicable accounting standards, ensuring a transparent representation of the company’s financial position.

2. Compliance Requirements

2.1. Accessibility of Records

• Legal Requirement: Books of account must be accessible within India at all times.
• Interpretation: Companies utilizing cloud-based accounting systems must ensure authorized personnel can access these records efficiently and securely.

2.2. Audit Trail Requirement

• Regulation: As per Rule 3 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, companies using accounting software must ensure it enables the recording of an audit trail.
• Interpretation: An audit trail ensures transparency and accountability, recording all transactions chronologically, which is crucial for regulatory compliance.

2.3. Data Integrity and Preservation

• Regulation: Electronic records must be maintained without alteration as per the Companies (Accounts) Rules.
• Interpretation: Companies must retain records in their original format, ensuring that data from branch offices reflects what was initially recorded.

2.4. Statutory Records Maintenance

• Section 88: Companies must maintain a register of members, accessible at the registered office.
• Section 189: Minutes of meetings must be kept at the registered office during business hours, regardless of where they are maintained.
• Rule 8 of the Companies (Management and Administration) Rules, 2014: Specifies the maintenance of statutory registers at designated locations.

2.5. Filing of Form AOC-5

• Regulation: Form AOC-5 must be filed with the Registrar of Companies within 30 days of the Board's decision to maintain books of account at a place other than the registered office.
• Legal Language: "A company shall file with the Registrar a notice of the situation of the books of account and any change in the location thereof."
• Interpretation: This form serves as a formal notification to the RoC about the location of the books of account, ensuring compliance with Section 128.

2.6. Maintenance of Other Statutory Records

• Company Secretary: Responsible for ensuring the upkeep of statutory registers and minutes.
• Location: Statutory records may be maintained at the registered office or any other location as permitted by law, ensuring they are accessible to members and the RoC as needed.

3. Penalties for Non-Compliance

Failure to comply with the provisions regarding the maintenance of books of account can result in significant penalties:

• Section 128(6): Imposes fines of ₹10,000 to ₹1,00,000 for failure to maintain books of account.
• Section 447: In cases of fraud, penalties can extend to imprisonment for up to 10 years and fines that may reach three times the amount involved in the fraud.
• Section 206: The RoC has the authority to inspect the books of accounts and can impose further penalties for non-compliance or inaccuracies found during audits.

4. Best Practices for Maintenance of Books of Account

4.1. Leverage Technology

• Use Robust Accounting Software: Select software that meets legal requirements, providing comprehensive reporting and auditing features.

4.2. Conduct Regular Training

• Staff Training: Ensure that accounting personnel are well-versed in compliance requirements and best practices for maintaining records.

4.3. Implement Regular Backup Procedures

• Data Security: Regularly backup electronic records and ensure that backup data is stored securely.

4.4. Maintain Transparency in Reporting

• Communication: Maintain clear communication with stakeholders regarding the location and accessibility of books of account.

4.5. Seek Professional Advice

• Consult Legal Experts: Regularly consult with legal and accounting professionals to stay updated on regulatory changes and compliance requirements.

5. Conclusion

The meticulous maintenance of accurate and compliant books of account is not merely a legal obligation under the Companies Act, 2013, but a cornerstone of effective corporate governance. By adhering to the outlined legal requirements, leveraging technology, and implementing best practices, companies can ensure compliance and mitigate the risk of penalties. This guidance note serves as a comprehensive resource for companies to effectively navigate the complexities associated with maintaining books of account in India.

Updates on GST Compliance: Filing Deadlines and 7-Year Data Retention Policy

 As taxpayers navigate the evolving landscape of Goods and Services Tax (GST) compliance, it is essential to stay informed about recent regulatory changes that impact filing processes and data retention. Two critical updates that require immediate attention are the three-year filing limitation under Section 39(11) of the CGST Act, 2017 and the seven-year data retention policy on the GST portal. Below is a comprehensive overview of these updates, along with actionable steps for compliance.

1. Filing Restrictions Under Section 39(11) of the CGST Act, 2017

Effective 1st October 2023, Section 39(11), as implemented through Notification No. 28/2023 - Central Tax dated 31st July 2023, restricts taxpayers from filing GST returns:

• Filing Deadline: Taxpayers will not be allowed to file returns after 3 years from the due date of the return.

This provision underscores the importance of timely filing. Once the 3-year period has lapsed, the opportunity to file or rectify returns is permanently closed.

Action Required:

• Review and file any pending returns that are approaching the 3-year limit to avoid penalties and the risk of non-compliance.

2. GST Portal Data Retention Policy: Archiving Data Older Than 7 Years

In addition to the filing restrictions, the GST portal has implemented a data retention policy:

• Archiving Schedule: Data older than 7 years will be archived and removed from the GST portal on a monthly basis.

Key Dates:

• On 1st August 2024, return data for July 2017 will be archived.
• On 1st September 2024, return data for August 2017 will follow.
• On 1st October 2024, return data for September 2017 will be archived, and this process will continue monthly.

This means that as time progresses, access to historical return data will be restricted.

3. Immediate Steps for Taxpayers: Download Historical Data

Taxpayers must download and save all return data that is older than 7 years to ensure continued access to important historical records.

What to Do Now:

• Prioritize downloading return data for periods like July, August, and September 2017 before they are permanently archived.
• Establish a routine to regularly back up return data nearing the 7-year threshold.

4. Consequences of Non-Compliance

Failing to adhere to these new provisions could lead to:

• Inability to file returns after the 3-year deadline, resulting in penalties.
• Loss of vital return data needed for audits or reconciliations.

5. Stay Ahead: Ensure Timely Filing and Data Protection

Taxpayers are strongly encouraged to take immediate action to comply with these updated regulations. Filing returns within the 3-year limit and downloading historical data before it’s archived are essential steps for avoiding future complications.

For more insights and professional guidance on how to navigate these changes, visit casahuja.com or reach out to Sandeep Ahuja & Co Chartered Accountants.

Don’t wait—protect your GST return data and ensure timely filings to remain fully compliant under the latest regulations.

At a Glance: Key Compliance Points

Key Compliance Points	Details
Three-Year Filing Deadline (Section 39(11))	Taxpayers cannot file GST returns after 3 years from the due date. This rule is effective from 1st October 2023.
Applicable Notification	Implemented via Notification No. 28/2023 - Central Tax dated 31st July 2023.
Action Required for Filing	Ensure all pending GST returns are filed within 3 years to avoid permanent closure of the filing window.
GST Portal Data Retention Policy	Data older than 7 years will be archived and removed from the GST portal on a monthly basis.
Key Archive Dates	- 1st August 2024: Data for July 2017 archived - 1st September 2024: Data for August 2017 archived - 1st October 2024: Data for September 2017 archived.
Future Data Archival	Data will be archived monthly as it crosses the 7-year limit.
Action Required for Data	Download and save all return data older than 7 years for future reference before it’s permanently archived.
Consequences of Non-Compliance	- Inability to file returns after the 3-year limit - Permanent loss of archived data after 7 years
This consolidated overview ensures that taxpayers are well-informed about their obligations and the necessary actions to take in light of these critical updates.

Growth through Government e-Marketplace (GeM): Your Path to Success in Public Procurement

"Success in business is all about connections, opportunities, and timing. With GeM, all three come together for your growth."
– Anonymous

In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) stands as a transformative platform that enables businesses of all sizes to tap into the vast pool of government procurement opportunities. Established to create a transparent, efficient, and paperless procurement process, GeM is revolutionizing the way public sector organizations procure goods and services. From ministries to public sector enterprises, the platform serves as the single point for connecting businesses with government buyers.

As a cornerstone of the Digital India and Aatmanirbhar Bharat initiatives, GeM aligns with the government's vision of making the procurement process inclusive and economically viable. This is especially significant for Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) that are often hindered by traditional barriers when competing in government tenders. The recent reforms, which include reduced transaction fees, have further lowered the cost of doing business on the platform, making it more accessible to small businesses while boosting their growth potential.

Present Day Relevance: Why GeM Matters Now

GeM's relevance in today's marketplace cannot be overstated. With an increased focus on e-commerce and digitalization across sectors, the platform provides an easy and efficient way for businesses to reach government buyers—a customer base that represents a significant portion of the economy. The recent reduction in transaction charges also makes GeM a highly cost-effective tool for businesses that wish to participate in public procurement.

The government's efforts to promote transparency and reduce costs are part of a broader push to create a more competitive, fair, and efficient market for public procurement. In today’s competitive environment, every rupee saved and every opportunity seized can make a substantial difference in the growth trajectory of a business.

Key Government Initiatives to Promote Ease of Doing Business on GeM

To make GeM even more attractive and competitive, the government introduced several initiatives aimed at reducing barriers and improving the platform’s functionality. These include:

1. Zero Transaction Charges for Orders Up to ₹10 Lakh:

   • Effective August 9, 2024, businesses no longer pay transaction fees for orders up to ₹10 lakh, providing an immediate boost to MSMEs and startups.

2. Reduced Fees for Orders Between ₹10 Lakh and ₹10 Crore:

   • Transaction fees for these orders have been reduced to 0.30%, down from 0.45%, significantly lowering costs for medium-sized businesses.

3. Capped Fees for Large Contracts (Above ₹10 Crore):

   • For larger contracts, the maximum fee has been reduced to ₹3 lakh, from the previous ₹72.5 lakh, ensuring affordability for companies handling high-value projects.

These changes make 97% of transactions on GeM completely fee-free, creating a level playing field for all businesses, regardless of size.

Step-by-Step Guide to Registering and Selling on GeM

The GeM portal is designed to be user-friendly and accessible, ensuring that even businesses with limited resources can register and begin selling in no time. Here's a comprehensive guide on how to get started:

Step 1: Visit the GeM Portal

• Navigate to the official website gem.gov.in and select ‘Sign Up’ to begin your registration.

Step 2: Choose Your Category

• You can register as either a seller of goods or a service provider. Select the option that matches your business offering.

Step 3: Provide Business Information

• Enter essential business details, including:
  • PAN (Permanent Account Number) or GSTIN (if applicable).
  • Bank account information for payments.
  • Business address and contact details.

Step 4: Upload Required Documents

• You will need to provide the following documentation:
  • Business registration certificates (e.g., Certificate of Incorporation).
  • Identity verification (PAN card, Aadhaar).
  • Bank statement or cancelled cheque.

Step 5: Complete Your Profile and List Products or Services

• Once registered, log into your Seller Dashboard to:
  • Upload product listings with detailed descriptions and images.
  • Set pricing, delivery timelines, and terms such as warranties and shipping policies.

Step 6: Verification and Approval

• After submission, your application will be reviewed. Upon approval, your profile and offerings will become visible to government buyers.

Step 7: Start Bidding and Selling

• Participate in e-bidding and reverse auction processes for relevant tenders. Once selected, you can manage orders and payments through the platform.

Benefits of Selling on GeM

GeM offers a host of benefits for businesses, including:

1. Cost Savings:

   • The revised fee structure eliminates transaction fees for most businesses, significantly reducing costs for MSMEs and startups. Orders up to ₹10 lakh are now fee-free, and fees for larger contracts have been significantly reduced.

2. Transparency and Fair Competition:

   • The platform's e-bidding system ensures that all sellers have an equal opportunity to compete, promoting a transparent and fair market.

3. Wider Reach and Visibility:

   • By registering on GeM, businesses gain access to a vast network of government buyers. The platform allows for seamless transactions and wider market reach, including across multiple government departments.

4. Timely Payments and Reduced Paperwork:

   • GeM's digital-first approach ensures efficient payments directly into your bank account, reducing delays that are typical in traditional procurement methods. The platform also minimizes paperwork, streamlining the entire process from bidding to delivery.

5. Incentives for MSMEs, Startups, and Women Entrepreneurs:

   • The government provides several preferential schemes for MSMEs, women-owned businesses, and startups on GeM, increasing their chances of winning contracts and benefiting from the platform.

Why GeM is a Game-Changer for Your Business

In a world where digital innovation is the key to competitive advantage, GeM offers a game-changing opportunity for businesses looking to expand their reach within the public sector. It opens doors to government buyers that were traditionally difficult to access and provides a cost-effective and transparent procurement system that benefits both small and large businesses alike.

GeM represents more than just a procurement platform—it is an opportunity to contribute to the growth of India's economy while aligning with national initiatives like Digital India and Aatmanirbhar Bharat. Whether you're a small business owner or part of a large corporation, GeM provides the tools and platform to succeed in public procurement.

By leveraging the GeM platform, businesses can unlock new opportunities, drive growth, and ensure long-term success in India’s evolving marketplace.

Tax audit Requirements for AY 2024-25: A Clear Guide to Section 44AB with Key Checkpoints

The Income Tax Act mandates businesses and professionals to undergo an audit under certain conditions to ensure transparency and accuracy in financial reporting. Section 44AB specifies the circumstances under which an audit is compulsory, including different provisions for presumptive tax schemes like Section 44AD, 44ADA, and Section 44AE.

From AY 2024-25, the turnover limits for audit exemption have been updated, providing some relief to businesses and professionals with low cash transactions. This guide simplifies the conditions under which an audit is required or exempted and provides a clear breakdown of the relevant clauses and subsections for each scenario.

Key Checkpoints Before Deciding Audit Requirement:

1. Turnover Limit: The turnover or gross receipts of your business or profession for the financial year.
2. Cash Receipts & Payments: Whether cash transactions exceed 5% of total receipts and payments.
3. Presumptive Taxation: Are you opting for Section 44AD, 44ADA, or 44AE, and if so, are you declaring profits as per the prescribed percentage?
4. Previous Years: If you’ve opted out of Section 44AD after choosing it earlier, you'll need an audit for the next 5 years.
5. Audit under Other Laws: If your accounts are already audited under other laws (e.g., Companies Act), check whether a separate audit is still necessary.

Audit Requirement Table for AY 2024-25

S. No.	Condition	Turnover / Receipts	Audit Required	Clause & Subsection of Section 44AB
1	Business with turnover up to Rs. 1 Crore	Up to Rs. 1 Crore	No	Not applicable
2	Business with turnover exceeding Rs. 1 Crore but up to Rs. 2 Crores (Opting for Section 44AD)	Rs. 1 Cr. to Rs. 2 Cr.	No, if profit ≥ 6% (digital) or 8% (cash)	Clause (a), Section 44AD
3	Business with turnover up to Rs. 3 Crores (From 1st April 2024)	Up to Rs. 3 Crores	No, if cash receipts ≤ 5%	Proviso to Clause (a)
4	Business with turnover up to Rs. 10 Crores (From 1st April 2024)	Up to Rs. 10 Crores	No, if cash receipts & payments ≤ 5%	Proviso to Clause (a)
5	Business with turnover exceeding Rs. 10 Crores	Above Rs. 10 Crores	Yes	Clause (a)
6	Professional with receipts up to Rs. 50 Lakhs (Opting for Section 44ADA)	Up to Rs. 50 Lakhs	No, if 50% profit declared	Clause (b), Section 44ADA
7	Professional with receipts up to Rs. 75 Lakhs (From 1st April 2024)	Up to Rs. 75 Lakhs	No, if cash receipts ≤ 5%	Proviso to Clause (b)
8	Professional with receipts exceeding Rs. 75 Lakhs	Above Rs. 75 Lakhs	Yes	Clause (b)
9	Business opting out of Section 44AD after opting in	N/A	Yes for 5 years after opting out	Clause (e), Section 44AD(4)
10	Business or profession declaring lower profits than required under Section 44AD / 44ADA	N/A	Yes	Clause (d), Section 44AD/44ADA
11	Goods carriage business under Section 44AE declaring lower profits	N/A	Yes	Clause (c), Section 44AE
12	Oil exploration or aircraft operations under Section 44BB / 44BBB declaring lower profits	N/A	Yes	Clause (c), Section 44BB/44BBB
13	Accounts audited under any other law (e.g. Companies Act)	N/A	No, if audit report filed on time under other law	Clause (f)

Audit Exemptions:

• Businesses with turnover up to Rs. 10 Crores are exempt from audit if cash receipts and cash payments are less than 5% of total transactions.
• Professionals with receipts up to Rs. 75 Lakhs (from 1st April 2024) can avoid audit if they declare 50% profits and have cash receipts ≤ 5%.
• Presumptive Tax schemes provide relief if businesses and professionals meet the required profit percentages and turnover limits.

Conclusion:

Audits under Section 44AB ensure that businesses and professionals maintain proper financial records and compliance. With recent amendments increasing turnover thresholds, many small businesses and professionals can benefit from audit exemptions, provided they maintain low cash transactions and declare adequate profits under presumptive taxation schemes. Always refer to the specific conditions under each clause to determine your audit obligations and avoid penalties.

Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme, 2024: Comprehensive Guide for Taxpayers

The Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme, 2024 (DTVSV 2024) is a pivotal initiative by the Indian government aimed at resolving pending direct tax disputes. Effective from October 1, 2024, this scheme enables taxpayers to settle their disputes with the Income Tax Department under favorable terms, promoting compliance and reducing litigation.

1. Objectives of the Scheme

• Reduce Litigation Backlog: Alleviate the pressure on judicial resources by minimizing the number of pending tax cases.
• Facilitate Voluntary Compliance: Encourage taxpayers to resolve their disputes and comply with tax laws.
• Financial Relief: Provide substantial reductions in taxes, penalties, and interest for early settlements.

2. Legal Framework

The scheme operates under the Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2024, detailing the eligibility, exclusions, procedures, and settlement terms. It is designed to offer a structured approach for resolving disputes and includes:

• Definition of Eligible Disputes: Any disputes related to direct taxes under the Income Tax Act, 1961.
• Scope of Settlement: Settlements can include disputes over disputed tax amounts, penalties, and interest.

3. Eligibility Criteria

Taxpayers can avail themselves of the scheme if they meet the following criteria:

• Pending Appeals: Must have pending appeals or writ petitions before:
  • Supreme Court
  • High Courts
  • Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT)
  • Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) (CIT-A)
• Types of Disputes: Includes disputes over tax assessments, interest, penalties, and cases arising from search and seizure.

4. Exclusions from the Scheme

The following cases are not eligible for settlement under the DTVSV 2024:

Exclusion Category	Details
Prosecution Cases	Involves serious offences like wilful tax evasion or concealment.
Undisclosed Foreign Income/Assets	Related to income or assets that have not been disclosed to the authorities.
Benami Transactions	Governed by the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, these involve hidden ownership.
Serious Tax Offences	Includes cases under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and others.

5. Settlement Terms and Payment Structure

The financial relief offered under the scheme varies based on the timing of the settlement and the nature of the dispute. Here’s a detailed breakdown:

Nature of Dispute	Settlement Amount (Before December 31, 2024)	Settlement Amount (After December 31, 2024)
Disputed Tax	100% of the disputed tax	110% of the disputed tax
Disputed Penalty	25% of the disputed penalty	30% of the disputed penalty
Disputed Interest	25% of the disputed interest	30% of the disputed interest
Search and Seizure Cases	100% of tax on undisclosed income	110% of tax on undisclosed income
Transfer Pricing Adjustments	As per applicable percentages of disputed tax	Additional surcharge of 10% to 20% post-December 31, 2024

6. Procedure for Availing the Scheme

The process for taxpayers to settle their disputes is straightforward:

Step	Action Required
Step 1: Declaration Filing	Submit an electronic declaration through the Income Tax e-filing portal.
Step 2: Withdrawal of Appeal	Withdraw any related appeals or writ petitions from the courts/tribunals.
Step 3: Calculation of Amount	Tax authorities will compute the payable amount based on the declaration.
Step 4: Payment of Amount	Pay the determined amount within 30 days of receiving the order.
Step 5: Issuance of Certificate	Receive a settlement certificate upon payment, finalizing the dispute.

7. Key Dates and Timeline

Milestone	Date
Scheme Commencement	October 1, 2024
Early Settlement Deadline	December 31, 2024
Late Settlement Surcharge Begins	January 1, 2025

8. Benefits of the Scheme

The DTVSV 2024 offers several advantages to eligible taxpayers:

Benefit	Explanation
Financial Relief	Substantial reductions in disputed taxes, penalties, and interest, leading to lower overall liabilities.
Time Efficiency	Quick resolution of disputes saves time and avoids prolonged litigation costs.
Certainty and Finality	Settlements close disputes definitively, preventing future claims or reopening of cases.
Encourages Compliance	Facilitates voluntary compliance, encouraging taxpayers to settle past issues amicably.
Simplified Process	Clear and straightforward procedural steps make participation easy for taxpayers.

9. Strategic Considerations for Taxpayers

• Evaluate Your Case: Taxpayers should assess their individual situations and the strength of their positions before deciding to settle.
• Consider Financial Impact: Calculate potential savings from reduced penalties and interest against the total disputed amount.
• Consult Professionals: Seek advice from tax consultants or chartered accountants to navigate the complexities of the scheme effectively.

10. Conclusion

The Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Scheme, 2024 presents a valuable opportunity for taxpayers to resolve long-standing tax disputes efficiently and affordably. The scheme is particularly advantageous for those with significant tax liabilities, as it offers a clear pathway to compliance while reducing financial burdens. 

Detailed Procedure for Handling Auditor Resignation and Appointment

Managing the resignation of an auditor and the appointment of a new auditor involves precise adherence to the statutory requirements under the Companies Act, 2013 and the Income Tax Act, 1961. This guidance note provides a comprehensive step-by-step procedure, including detailed timelines and precautions to ensure compliance and avoid defaults.

I. Legal Framework and Compliance Requirements

A. Resignation of Auditor

1. Submission of Resignation Letter:

   • Action: The auditor must submit a formal resignation letter to the Board of Directors.
   • Content: The letter should detail the reasons for resignation.
   • Timing: The letter should be submitted immediately upon the decision to resign.

2. Filing Form ADT-3:

   • Responsibility: The outgoing auditor must file Form ADT-3 with the Registrar of Companies (RoC).
   • Deadline: 30 days from the date of resignation.
   • Content: Form ADT-3 should include the reasons for resignation and details of any pending issues or disputes.
   • Verification: The company should follow up to ensure Form ADT-3 is filed and obtain a confirmation receipt.

3. Consequences of Non-Compliance:

   • Penalties: Failure to file Form ADT-3 within the prescribed period can result in penalties of up to Rs. 10,000 plus Rs. 100 per day for continuing defaults.

II. Procedure for Managing Auditor Resignation

A. Board Meeting to Accept Resignation

1. Convening the Board Meeting:

   • Timing: The Board must convene a meeting as soon as possible upon receiving the resignation letter.
   • Agenda: The meeting should cover the acknowledgment of the resignation, acceptance, and next steps for appointing a new auditor.

2. Minutes of the Meeting:

   • Documentation: The minutes should record the acceptance of the resignation, the reasons provided, and the date of resignation.
   • Resolution: Pass a resolution to accept the resignation and note the effective date.

3. Intimation to RoC:

   • The company should confirm that the outgoing auditor has filed Form ADT-3 and retain a copy of the form and confirmation receipt for records.

III. Appointment of New Auditor

A. Filling the Casual Vacancy

1. Board Meeting to Appoint New Auditor:

   • Timing: Convene the Board meeting within 30 days of the resignation.
   • Eligibility Check: Verify that the new auditor meets the eligibility criteria under Section 141 of the Companies Act, 2013.
   • Consent: Obtain the new auditor's consent to act and a certificate of eligibility.

2. Passing of Board Resolution:

   • Resolution: Pass a resolution to appoint the new auditor. Ensure the resolution states that the appointment is subject to ratification by shareholders at the next General Meeting.

3. Filing Form ADT-1:

   • Deadline: File Form ADT-1 with the RoC within 15 days from the passing of the resolution.
   • Content: Include details of the new auditor, their consent, and other required information.
   • Mode of Filing: File electronically through the MCA portal, and ensure payment of the requisite fee.

B. Shareholder Ratification

1. AGM/EGM Inclusion:

   • AGM: If the Annual General Meeting (AGM) is scheduled within three months, include the new auditor’s appointment in the agenda.
   • Notice: Issue a clear 21-day notice prior to the AGM as per Section 101.

2. Calling an EGM if Necessary:

   • Procedure: If the AGM is not imminent, call an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) to seek ratification.
   • Notice: Provide a clear 21-day notice for the EGM unless members holding at least 95% of paid-up share capital consent to a shorter notice.

3. Passing of Ordinary Resolution:

   • Resolution: At the AGM or EGM, pass an Ordinary Resolution to ratify the appointment of the new auditor.
   • Minutes: Document the resolution in the meeting minutes and file with the RoC if required.

IV. Compliance with Income Tax Act

A. Tax Audit Compliance (Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961)

1. Completion of Tax Audit:

   • Timing: The new auditor must complete the tax audit for the financial year 2023-24 by 30th September 2024.
   • Preparation: Ensure all necessary financial records and documents are available to the new auditor.

2. Filing of Tax Audit Report:

   • Forms: Submit the tax audit report electronically in Form 3CA/3CB and Form 3CD.
   • Penalties: Delays in filing may incur penalties under Section 271B, up to 0.5% of turnover or Rs. 1,50,000, whichever is lower.

V. Precautionary Measures to Avoid Defaults

1. Timely Meetings and Filings:

   • Board Meeting: Ensure that the Board Meeting to accept the resignation and appoint a new auditor is conducted within the stipulated timeframes.
   • Filing Forms: Ensure Forms ADT-1 and ADT-3 are filed promptly to avoid penalties.

2. Accurate Documentation:

   • Record-Keeping: Maintain accurate records of all resolutions, notices, and filings related to the resignation and appointment of the auditor.
   • Minutes and Forms: Ensure all minutes and forms are correctly filled and submitted.

3. No Objection Certificate (NOC):

   • Best Practice: Although not mandatory, obtain a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the outgoing auditor to facilitate a smoother transition and address potential disputes.

Conclusion

Handling the resignation of an auditor and appointing a new one involves meticulous attention to statutory requirements under the Companies Act, 2013, and the Income Tax Act, 1961. By following the detailed procedures outlined in this guidance note, companies can ensure compliance, avoid penalties, and facilitate a smooth transition. Consulting with legal and financial experts is advisable to address specific concerns and ensure full adherence to all statutory obligations.

Maximizing Tax Benefits with Section 80JJAA - Part II

 Section 80JJAA of the Income Tax Act is designed to encourage businesses to expand their workforce, thereby contributing to employment growth and economic development. This guide provides a comprehensive illustration of how to calculate and claim deductions under Section 80JJAA, including a detailed analysis of the impact of employee numbers on eligibility and compliance.

Eligibility and Compliance for Section 80JJAA

Eligibility Criteria:

1. Employee Eligibility:

   • Monthly Salary: Up to ₹25,000.
   • Employment Duration: Must be employed for more than 240 days in the previous financial year.
   • Provident Fund Membership: Employees must be members of a recognized Provident Fund.

2. Employer/Business Eligibility:

   • Operational Period: The business must have been operational for at least 240 days in the previous year.
   • Minimum Employees: The business must have employed a minimum of 10 employees in the preceding year.
   • Previous Claims: The business must not have claimed this deduction in any prior year.

3. Deduction Rate:

   • 30% of the additional employee cost incurred in the previous year for hiring eligible employees.

Illustrative Calculation:

Financial Years: 2024-25, 2025-26, and 2026-27

Initial Data:

Description	FY 2024-25	FY 2025-26	FY 2026-27
Employee Cost in Previous Year	₹80,00,000	₹105,00,000	₹120,00,000
Employee Cost in Current Year	₹105,00,000	₹120,00,000	₹140,00,000
Additional Employee Cost	₹25,00,000	₹15,00,000	₹20,00,000
Deduction Rate	30%	30%	30%
Deduction Under Section 80JJAA	₹7,50,000	₹4,50,000	₹6,00,000

Detailed Calculation:

1. FY 2024-25:

   • Employee Cost in Previous Year: ₹80,00,000
   • Employee Cost in Current Year: ₹105,00,000
   • Additional Employee Cost: ₹105,00,000 - ₹80,00,000 = ₹25,00,000
   • Deduction Under Section 80JJAA: 30% of ₹25,00,000 = ₹7,50,000

2. FY 2025-26:

   • Employee Cost in Previous Year: ₹105,00,000
   • Employee Cost in Current Year: ₹120,00,000
   • Additional Employee Cost: ₹120,00,000 - ₹105,00,000 = ₹15,00,000
   • Deduction Under Section 80JJAA: 30% of ₹15,00,000 = ₹4,50,000

3. FY 2026-27:

   • Employee Cost in Previous Year: ₹120,00,000
   • Employee Cost in Current Year: ₹140,00,000
   • Additional Employee Cost: ₹140,00,000 - ₹120,00,000 = ₹20,00,000
   • Number of Employees Reduced: Suppose the total number of employees decreases to 65 (from 70)
   • Deduction Under Section 80JJAA: 30% of ₹20,00,000 = ₹6,00,000

Note: Ensure the reduction in the number of employees does not impact eligibility criteria. If the total number of employees falls below the minimum required threshold of 10 employees, reassess and adjust the claim as necessary.

Impact of Employee Numbers and Salary Levels:

1. Reduction in Number of Employees:

   • Ensure that the reduction in the number of employees does not affect eligibility. If the total number of employees falls below the required threshold of 10 employees, eligibility for the deduction may be impacted. For example, if your business had 15 employees in FY 2025-26 but reduced to 9 employees in FY 2026-27, you must reassess your eligibility for the deduction. Adjust the claim based on the current workforce and verify compliance with the eligibility criteria for the deduction.

2. High Salary of Eligible Employees:

   • If any employee's monthly salary exceeds ₹25,000 in the second or third year, that employee will not be eligible for the deduction. For example, if an employee in FY 2025-26 earns ₹30,000 per month, they will not be considered for the additional employee cost deduction for that year. Therefore, any additional employee costs claimed must be based solely on employees whose monthly salary is up to ₹25,000.

Filling Out Form 10DA:

For claiming the deduction under Section 80JJAA, you need to complete Form 10DA. This form requires detailed information about eligible employees and their employment conditions. Here’s how to fill it out:

Year	Number of Eligible Employees	Monthly Salary	Days Employed	Total Employee Cost	Additional Employee Cost	Deduction Claimed
2024-25	15	₹20,000	260	₹105,00,000	₹25,00,000	₹7,50,000
2025-26	12	₹22,000	250	₹120,00,000	₹15,00,000	₹4,50,000
2026-27	10	₹24,000	245	₹140,00,000	₹20,00,000	₹6,00,000

Key Considerations and Cautions:

1. Contractual Labor Exclusion:

   • Deductions under Section 80JJAA are not applicable for contractual labor. Ensure that only permanent employees are considered for the deduction.

2. Provident Fund Requirement:

   • Employees must be members of a recognized Provident Fund. Verify that all additional employees meet this requirement to qualify for the deduction.

3. Impact of Employee Numbers:

   • Ensure the reduction in the number of employees does not affect eligibility. If the total number of employees falls below the required threshold of 10 employees, eligibility for the deduction may be impacted. Reassess and adjust the claim based on the current workforce.

4. High Salary of Eligible Employees:

   • Employees earning more than ₹25,000 per month are ineligible. Ensure that the calculation of additional employee costs excludes any employees with salaries exceeding this limit.

5. Documentation and Compliance:

   • Maintain accurate records and documentation for all additional employee costs. Ensure compliance with eligibility criteria to avoid disputes with the tax authorities.

6. Penalties for Incorrect Claims:

   • Incorrect claims under Section 80JJAA can attract penalties under Section 271(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act. Penalties can range from 100% to 300% of the tax sought to be evaded. Additional tax liabilities, reassessments, and interest may also apply.

By carefully managing employee numbers, maintaining proper documentation, and ensuring compliance with eligibility criteria, businesses can effectively leverage Section 80JJAA to maximize tax benefits and support employment growth.

No Addition for Stock Discrepancies Based on Statements Submitted to Bankers

 One of the recurring issues faced by taxpayers and tax authorities is the treatment of stock discrepancies between books of accounts and the stock statements submitted to banks. In the recent decision of ITO v. M.M. Poonjiaji Spices (P.) Ltd., the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) provided clarity on the circumstances under which such discrepancies may or may not lead to an addition in the taxpayer’s income. This case reaffirms the principles laid out in earlier judicial precedents and highlights the importance of substantiating any addition with robust evidence.

Understanding the Stock Discrepancy Dilemma:

In the normal course of business, entities submit stock statements to banks for the purpose of securing loans or credit lines. However, these stock figures often diverge from those recorded in the company’s books of accounts. The reasons for these discrepancies could include:

• Valuation Differences: Businesses may adopt a different method of valuation for stock submitted to banks, often inflating figures to reflect a stronger financial position.
• Temporal Differences: The stock reported to banks may reflect a snapshot at a specific point in time, which might not coincide with the stock as recorded at the end of a financial period.
• Banking Practices: Sometimes, businesses submit conservative or inflated estimates to maintain creditworthiness.

In M.M. Poonjiaji Spices (P.) Ltd., the discrepancy arose between the stock shown in the books of accounts and those reported to the bank. The Assessing Officer (AO), relying on the higher figure submitted to the bank, added the difference to the assessee’s income, assuming that the higher stock value represented the true stock position, thus indicating suppression of income. However, both the Commissioner (Appeals) and the ITAT rejected this addition.

Key Legal Considerations:

1. Bank Statements Are Not Conclusive Evidence:

   • Stock statements submitted to banks are intended to secure credit facilities and are not subject to the same scrutiny as audited financial statements. Courts have consistently held that these figures do not constitute conclusive evidence of actual stock levels or income. The ITAT reaffirmed this position, highlighting that bank figures are often inflated for obtaining credit.

2. Need for Independent Corroboration:

   • Any income addition must be supported by independent evidence. The Revenue must prove that the stock reported to the bank accurately reflects the true stock, and that the books of accounts were manipulated to suppress income. Without such corroboration, a discrepancy alone is insufficient to warrant an addition.

3. Reconciliation and Justification by the Taxpayer:

   • In the case, the assessee provided a reasonable explanation for the discrepancy, citing differences in valuation methods and timing. The Tribunal accepted this explanation, noting that there was no deliberate suppression of income. A well-maintained reconciliation can prevent unnecessary additions.

Precedents Supporting the Tribunal’s Ruling:

1. CIT v. Apcom Computers (P.) Ltd. (Madras High Court):

   • The High Court ruled that discrepancies between stock in books and bank submissions do not automatically justify an addition. It recognized that stock figures provided to banks are often inflated to secure higher credit limits and are not conclusive evidence of stock on hand.

2. CIT v. Shree Padmavati Cotton Mills Ltd. (Gujarat High Court):

   • The court emphasized that discrepancies between stock figures submitted to banks and those in books of accounts cannot justify an income addition, especially when the assessee’s books are regularly maintained and audited. The court recognized that stock statements provided to banks are often inflated for business reasons.

Critical Analysis of the Tribunal’s Rationale:

The ruling in M.M. Poonjiaji Spices emphasizes that discrepancies in stock values reported to banks cannot be the sole basis for an addition unless backed by substantial evidence. Several key points reinforce this view:

• Purpose of Stock Statements: The figures submitted to banks serve to secure credit facilities and are often influenced by business needs, making them unsuitable for tax assessments.
• Lack of Verification: Banks do not independently verify stock figures, further undermining their use as conclusive evidence.
• Requirement of Evidence: For any addition, the Revenue must present clear evidence showing manipulation of stock figures or suppression of income.

Conclusion: The Prevailing Judicial Approach

The case of M.M. Poonjiaji Spices (P.) Ltd. consolidates the judicial view that discrepancies in stock statements submitted to banks cannot be used to justify income additions without corroborative evidence. Courts have consistently ruled that these figures are often inflated for business purposes and do not reflect the actual stock for tax purposes.

For tax authorities, it is crucial to look beyond stock discrepancies and gather substantial evidence before making income additions. For taxpayers, maintaining clear reconciliation and understanding different stock valuations can help avoid litigation.

Analytical Guidance on Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) Under GST

In-Depth Analysis of Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) Under GST

The Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) under Goods and Services Tax (GST) shifts the responsibility for paying GST from the supplier to the recipient of goods or services. This mechanism plays a critical role in enhancing tax compliance and mitigating evasion, particularly when dealing with unregistered suppliers or high-risk sectors.

Recent Developments and Their Strategic Impact

1. 54th GST Council Meeting:

   • Change: Commercial property rental transactions conducted by unregistered persons with registered persons are now subject to RCM.
   • Impact: This adjustment addresses significant revenue leakage from the rental sector, where unregistered lessors previously avoided GST obligations. By imposing RCM on such transactions, the GST system ensures that tax liability is borne by the registered recipient, who is more likely to comply with tax regulations. This measure is expected to strengthen revenue collection and enhance the integrity of the GST system.

2. Enhancement of GST Portal:

   • Change: Introduction of the RCM Liability/ITC Statement for the reporting of transactions under RCM.
   • Impact: The new statement streamlines the reporting process for RCM transactions, improving transparency and accuracy. This enhancement facilitates more efficient tracking and reporting of RCM-related transactions, reduces administrative burden, and ensures that input tax credits (ITC) are claimed correctly, aligning with broader compliance objectives.

3. 53rd GST Council Meeting Clarification:

   • Change: ITC claims for purchases under RCM from unregistered suppliers will be based on the invoice date within the financial year.
   • Impact: This clarification standardizes the ITC claiming process, reducing ambiguity and aligning it with invoice issuance. By harmonizing ITC claims with the financial year of the invoice, this change simplifies accounting practices and enhances compliance, supporting more accurate and efficient tax administration.

Scope and Applicability of RCM

RCM applies under the following conditions:

1. Imports:

   • Impact: GST under RCM for imports requires the recipient to pay GST in addition to import duties. This ensures that imports are subject to GST on par with domestic transactions, maintaining tax consistency and preventing competitive disadvantage for domestic suppliers.

2. Purchases from Unregistered Dealers:

   • Impact: When a registered recipient procures goods or services from an unregistered dealer, the GST liability is shifted to the recipient. This mechanism effectively mitigates tax evasion risks associated with unregistered suppliers and ensures that tax obligations are fulfilled by entities with established compliance frameworks.

3. Supply of Notified Goods and Services:

   • Impact: Certain goods and services designated by the government are subject to RCM. This targeted approach helps manage compliance in sectors prone to evasion, ensuring that tax collection is streamlined and regulatory focus is directed where it is most needed.

RCM Provisions in GST Returns

1. GSTR 1 & GSTR 2:

   • Change: Registered suppliers cannot claim input tax credit for supplies under RCM; the recipient must report these transactions in GSTR 1 and GSTR 2.
   • Impact: This provision ensures that the responsibility for RCM-related tax payments is accurately captured and reported. It prevents misuse of ITC and centralizes tax obligations with the recipient, facilitating effective compliance monitoring and reporting.

2. Imports:

   • Impact: GST paid under RCM for imports is supplementary to import duties, ensuring that all imported goods are taxed consistently. This comprehensive approach maintains uniformity in GST application across different types of transactions.

3. Registration Requirement:

   • Impact: Entities required to pay tax under RCM must be GST-registered, regardless of turnover. This requirement ensures that all parties involved in RCM transactions are subject to regulatory oversight, thereby enhancing compliance and reducing the potential for evasion.

Input Tax Credit (ITC)

• Change: ITC is available to the recipient for taxes paid under RCM, provided it is utilized for business purposes.
• Impact: Granting ITC for RCM payments supports business liquidity and ensures that GST paid is recoverable. This provision fosters fair tax practices by allowing businesses to offset RCM taxes against their output tax liabilities, thereby promoting adherence to GST regulations and enhancing operational efficiency.

Services Covered Under RCM

The following services are subject to RCM:

• Goods Transport Agency
• Recovery Agent
• Director of a company or body corporate
• Individual advocate or firm of advocates
• Insurance agent

Impact: Including these services under RCM addresses challenges related to tax compliance and enforcement in sectors where monitoring is complex. This strategic inclusion helps in reducing tax evasion and improving overall tax collection efficacy.

Conclusion

The Reverse Charge Mechanism under GST is a crucial component of the tax framework, designed to improve compliance and reduce evasion. Recent updates and strategic changes in RCM application highlight the commitment to enhancing tax administration and ensuring equitable tax practices. Businesses must stay informed of these changes and ensure compliance to maintain effective tax operations and contribute to the overall integrity of the GST system.

Mastering Section 80JJAA: Guide to Maximizing Tax Benefits with Compliance and Case Insights

Section 80JJAA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 has emerged as a crucial provision to promote employment generation, offering tax deductions to businesses for hiring new employees. Over the years, this section has undergone significant amendments, expanding its scope and applicability. Through this professional post, we will provide a detailed, case-based, and illustrative analysis of Section 80JJAA, emphasizing compliance, legal interpretations, and evolving changes.

The purpose is to offer not only a critical understanding of the section but also actionable insights for Chartered Accountants and businesses to maximize tax benefits while maintaining strict compliance. Additionally, we will highlight landmark cases and provide an improved compliance checklist for each stage of the process.

Evolution of Section 80JJAA: Key Amendments and Law Changes

1. Pre-2016: Focus on the Manufacturing Sector

Initially, Section 80JJAA was introduced to support the manufacturing sector, with strict eligibility requirements that restricted benefits to manufacturing businesses and imposed specific conditions on employees eligible for the deduction.

• Wage Limit: Employees earning less than ₹25,000 per month were eligible.
• Employee Work Duration: Employees needed to be employed for at least 300 days.

However, the stringent conditions limited the adoption of the benefit.

2. Post-2016: Expansion to All Sectors

The Finance Act, 2016 made significant amendments by broadening the applicability of Section 80JJAA to all businesses, removing the sectoral restriction. The minimum working days for employees were revised to 240 days for most businesses and 150 days for specific labor-intensive industries.

Key Changes:

• Applicability to All Sectors: Extended to all businesses, including non-manufacturing sectors.
• 150 Days for Specific Industries: Reduced working days for industries like footwear, apparel, and leather.
• Additional Employee Definition: Focus on "newly employed" workers enrolled in the provident fund scheme.

3. Landmark Case: Texas Instruments India Pvt. Ltd. vs. JCIT (2019)

In this case, the ITAT ruled that the deduction under Section 80JJAA applies to the gross addition of employees, even if the net number of employees doesn’t increase due to attrition. This ruling was crucial in clarifying that businesses can claim deductions for each new hire.

• Illustration: If Ashu Inc. hires 20 employees but loses 10 through attrition, the company can still claim the deduction for all 20 new hires under Section 80JJAA.

Key Takeaway: The deduction applies based on the gross additions of employees, irrespective of the net change.

4. Apex Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT (2016)

In this case, the Madras High Court highlighted that employees must meet the minimum 240 days' work requirement within the first year to be eligible for the deduction. The court ruled against prorating the period of employment.

Key Takeaway: The 240/150 days rule is strict, and no part-year deduction is allowed for those not meeting the threshold.

Current Legal Framework Under Section 80JJAA

As per the current provisions, Section 80JJAA allows a 30% deduction of the additional employee cost incurred in the relevant previous year. The deduction is available for three consecutive years, starting from the year of hiring.

Eligibility Criteria:

1. Newly Hired Employees: The employee must be hired during the financial year and work for at least 240 days in that year (or 150 days for specific industries like footwear, apparel, and leather).

2. Income Threshold: The employee’s monthly wage must not exceed ₹25,000.

3. Provident Fund Requirement: The employee must be covered under a provident fund scheme.

4. Businesses: Any business (irrespective of sector) can claim the benefit, provided the business meets the additional employee cost criteria.

5. Form 10DA Filing: The employer must file Form 10DA online, certified by a Chartered Accountant, along with the income tax return.

Illustrative Example

Scenario: Ashu Enterprises, a medium-sized garment business, hired 40 new employees during FY 2023-24. Of these, 30 employees earned less than ₹25,000 per month, worked for more than 150 days, and were enrolled in a provident fund scheme.

• Year 1 Deduction: Ashu Enterprises incurs an additional employee cost of ₹15 lakh. The company is eligible to claim a 30% deduction, amounting to ₹4.5 lakh for FY 2023-24.
• Year 2 Deduction: The company continues to claim ₹4.5 lakh for FY 2024-25, provided the employees remain eligible.

Outcome: Ashu Enterprises can claim this deduction for three consecutive years, totaling ₹13.5 lakh in tax benefits.

Key Case Laws: Detailed Interpretations

Infosys BPO Ltd. vs. ACIT (2015)

In this case, Infosys BPO was denied the deduction due to non-compliance with filing requirements. The ITAT ruled that businesses must submit Form 10DA certified by a CA before the due date to qualify for the deduction.

Key Takeaway: Timely filing of Form 10DA is critical for claiming deductions under Section 80JJAA.

Mphasis Ltd. vs. DCIT (2022)

This case clarified that rehiring employees from foreign offices or divisions is permitted under Section 80JJAA, provided they are first-time hires in India.

Key Takeaway: Rehiring from overseas divisions is allowed if they qualify as new employees in India.

Improved Compliance Checklist for Section 80JJAA

To avoid errors and maximize benefits under Section 80JJAA, businesses should follow this comprehensive year-by-year compliance checklist.

Year 1: Hiring Year

• Employee Tracking: Keep detailed records of all newly hired employees, ensuring they meet the 240-day (or 150-day) requirement.
• Salary Verification: Ensure that employees’ monthly wages are less than ₹25,000.
• Provident Fund Enrollment: Confirm that all eligible employees are enrolled in a provident fund scheme.
• File Form 10DA: Prepare and file Form 10DA electronically by the due date, certified by a Chartered Accountant.
• Maintain Documentation: Ensure all employee records, wage slips, and provident fund proofs are documented for audit purposes.

Year 2: Ongoing Compliance

• Re-evaluate Employee Eligibility: Recheck that employees continue to be eligible and are enrolled in the provident fund.
• Form 10DA Filing: File an updated Form 10DA certified by a CA for the second year, ensuring that the records align with the first year's data.
• Documentation Review: Maintain proper documentation to verify ongoing compliance with provident fund and wage requirements.

Year 3: Final Year of Deduction

• Final Deduction Claim: Calculate and claim the last installment of the 30% deduction for the eligible employees.
• Provident Fund Compliance: Ensure continuous compliance with provident fund regulations to avoid disallowances.
• Final Form 10DA Filing: File Form 10DA for the final year of deductions and retain certification by a CA.

Post-Compliance Audits

• Employee Records: Maintain all documentation for a minimum of 7 years to ensure compliance during future tax audits.
• Audit Preparation: Be prepared to provide proof of provident fund contributions, wage records, and copies of Form 10DA if required during assessments.

Minute Differences and Key Observations

1. Employee Eligibility Over Time:
   While the 150-day rule for certain industries like apparel has remained consistent, there have been calls for relaxing the 240-day rule for other industries, particularly start-ups, which typically hire seasonal workers.

2. Wage Limit:
   The ₹25,000 wage threshold has remained unchanged despite inflation and wage growth in the economy. This static limit has created some challenges for companies, especially those hiring skilled labor.

3. Overseas Hiring:
   Mphasis Ltd. clarified the eligibility of rehired employees from foreign divisions under Section 80JJAA, opening avenues for multi-national businesses to benefit from this deduction for employees relocated to India.

Conclusion: Maximize Benefits with Compliance

Section 80JJAA presents a valuable opportunity for businesses to lower their tax liability while fostering employment. However, it is essential to remain vigilant in ensuring compliance, especially with the timely filing of Form 10DA, and maintaining accurate employee records. By understanding the evolution of the law, businesses can strategically plan to maximize their tax deductions over three years.